It is often put forward as an objection to socialism that while it is a good idea, it will never happen because of 'human nature'. Supposedly, humans are naturally greedy, selfish and so couldn't possibly form a society based on cooperation and mutual benefit. The topic of the discussion in this branch meeting was 'human nature', introduced by SH. In a lively debate, the points were raised that there doesn't exist a single, fixed human nature, but that human nature is remarkable in that it is remarkably flexible and responsive to influences from the social and cultural environment. The idea that human nature is one which is fixed, and also biologically determined, is one that is commonplace in capitalist society, providing a useful justification for the continuing of capitalism and class society, as well as providing the rationale for the State, and a strictly limited representative 'democracy'.
The irony that capitalism causes the very behaviours of greed and selfishness in individuals, and yet these characteristics are used to stress the inevitabilty of the status quo, and that nothing better can be won, was not lost on those in the branch meeting.